Proposal RPi Linuxcnc Image Based on Raspi OS All welcome/encoraged to comment

After a bit of a discussion with forum member f355 it came to my attention that an image based on the "Raspiberry Pi Way" maybe possible. Whilst a little "terse" at first he did raise some valid point and gave me time to reconsider some things. And eat some humble pie. I would like to give thanks for this...sometimes it's needed to find a new direction.

One reason for this idea is to make using the image more familiar to those used to the RPi ecosystem. Being able to use the RPi imager and setup some defaults may be beneficial as well.

At the moment I'm experimenting with pi-gen ( github.com/RPi-Distro/pi-gen/tree/bookworm-arm64 ) target a bookworm based image, as I feel as time moves on and more familiarity is gained using the tool a working image with a RT kernel and Linuxcnc will be produced and can be compared to the existing image. Wifi seemed to be a bit of a issue from time to time.

Hopefully from this in the readme "Tool used to create Raspberry Pi OS images, and custom images based on Raspberry Pi OS, which was in turn derived from the Raspbian project." distribution should not be an issue.

So the first task is to create a basic image to get a feel for the tool.

All input whether positive or negative ( remember coming from Australia I'm somewhat hard to offend ) is welcomed and encouraged. Rather than the way it has happened in the past I would like this to be more of a community effort with regards to packages. Please remember the object is not to create a daily driver OS but one that makes the entry easier to running Linuxcnc on a Pi. Whilst it may be beneficial to include CAD\CAM I feel leaving this out will create a smaller image to download, and as there are many packages available half will be happy, half wont be and the other half may not have a preference.

As a final note the final decision will have to be made by the Linuxcnc hierarchy as I dont want to go against their wishes, but for the moment I think at least a discussion is good idea, and see what the community thinks.

Yes,yes I know some our esteemed members aren't exactly keen (not recommend) on the RPi due to cost factor.

Cheers
Rob

Any issues please post here
github.com/ozzyrob/pi-gen-linuxcnc

first of all, thanks for the kind(-ish, lol) words, I'm happy to be helpful to the community even if it is just planting ideas into smart people's minds

have you seen github.com/raspberrypi/rpi-image-gen ? to me it looks like a better fit for the purpose - all we need is to install some packages and configure some things, right? building the entire distro from scratch seems excessive.

Saw that, but was too lazy to setup the spare RPi. In fact that was what led me to pi-gen. Tho I haven't completely ruled it out.
Tho I do seem to like with pi-gen you can stop the process at certain stages.
Luckily or maybe not so I'm in a position where time is something I have plenty of. Also a couple of PC's I can use to build different configs. Sadly only one spare RPi400 and one spare RPi5, with the RPi5 being part of a very generous gift on Father's Day from my son.

f355 wrote:

I'm happy to be helpful to the community even if it is just planting ideas into smart people's minds

That is quite a habit to have, so use it as much as possible.

@f355

I've tried looking for a RT_PREEMPT kernel in the repos, but could only find kernels that were configured for Real time not Preemptive real time (which is what Linuxcnc requires).
Debian doesn't have any support for the RPi5 as it doesn't have enough upstream kernel support.
wiki.debian.org/RaspberryPiImages#Overview

and

raspi.debian.net/tested-images/

So to get a full RT_PREEMPT kernel the only solution it would seem is to roll our own. Which would not be a suitable solution for upgrading.

One solution maybe if Linuxcnc could host suitable kernels, but I really don't see the sense in a regular upgrade regarding the kernel in this situation. I'm still running the original kernel that was built whilst building the image in Jan 2025.

BTW running pi-gen builds a couple of flavours of images everything from lite to a fully image. Tho it does use a significant amount of disk space.

Debian includes a RT kernel for the Pi 4b and it is possible to get a working RT linuxcnc install using the Debian images. But the RT kernel was not installed as a dependency from linuxcnc-uspace and needed installing separately with something like sudo apt install linux-image-rt-$uname -r) (might not have that correct. The only catch is that the images only install a text terminal with a root user. You needed to add a user, add sudo rights and then install xfce to get a working system ut it is quite doable. Sadly it does not appear support continued to the pi5.