new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
- Zipdodar
- Offline
- New Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 8
- Thank you received: 0
19 Nov 2026 06:56 #350826
by Zipdodar
new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions??? was created by Zipdodar
Hey group!
I want to use software for motor control, cnc ideas and plans, and I want to be able to mess about, play with the settings etc.. and really get to understand the software I choose.
I think i like the idea of linuxcnc as it looks like it might be very powerful and can grow as I get into it, and has the ability to have up to 9 motor axis which is great..
But i am a bit unsure of linux cnc for a couple of reasons; could I get some feedback from other users, and from that, if it still sounds good i will get a computer, install it and have a play.
- Computer spec, I can never seem to find anywhere that says you need a xxxx spec computer..
I have read it is all about the latency and kernal which is software based and this needs to be good and right, and can only be tested once it is all installed..?
also i am sure i have read that a newer pc is not good for linux and linuc cnc?
Can a new modern PC be used?
if not what spec do i need to get and use?
- Is running on a Raspberry Pi a good idea? is it a powerful, capable control computer?
will the system have limitations on rasberry pi (or arduino or similer)
- If it works, then over time I wil be setting up multiple solutions on different computers / machines / projects.
But ideally, I want to do this in stages, so can I set it up on a pc or a raspberry pi or similer and play with it on the screen with nothing connected to learn stuff?
- For testing and learning, Can I have multiple setups on the machine side and just one computer, then load each setup as and when required?
Note: this wil be for testing and learning only; once I have got some skills, I wil then be setting up specific machines separately, each with their own controllers.
My plan is to have a board with a set of drivers, motors, switches etc.. as a test bed platform; this wil have both servos and steppers set up so both can be played with and tested.
I also have a cheapy xyz router table that is really small, just to test ideas and programs on.
I think it is called "Dongda" and is a Chinese tabletop machine with approximately 400 mm x 300 mm movement, perfect for a test machine with small stepping motors
I look forward to any input to assist me in getting started.
I want to use software for motor control, cnc ideas and plans, and I want to be able to mess about, play with the settings etc.. and really get to understand the software I choose.
I think i like the idea of linuxcnc as it looks like it might be very powerful and can grow as I get into it, and has the ability to have up to 9 motor axis which is great..
But i am a bit unsure of linux cnc for a couple of reasons; could I get some feedback from other users, and from that, if it still sounds good i will get a computer, install it and have a play.
- Computer spec, I can never seem to find anywhere that says you need a xxxx spec computer..
I have read it is all about the latency and kernal which is software based and this needs to be good and right, and can only be tested once it is all installed..?
also i am sure i have read that a newer pc is not good for linux and linuc cnc?
Can a new modern PC be used?
if not what spec do i need to get and use?
- Is running on a Raspberry Pi a good idea? is it a powerful, capable control computer?
will the system have limitations on rasberry pi (or arduino or similer)
- If it works, then over time I wil be setting up multiple solutions on different computers / machines / projects.
But ideally, I want to do this in stages, so can I set it up on a pc or a raspberry pi or similer and play with it on the screen with nothing connected to learn stuff?
- For testing and learning, Can I have multiple setups on the machine side and just one computer, then load each setup as and when required?
Note: this wil be for testing and learning only; once I have got some skills, I wil then be setting up specific machines separately, each with their own controllers.
My plan is to have a board with a set of drivers, motors, switches etc.. as a test bed platform; this wil have both servos and steppers set up so both can be played with and tested.
I also have a cheapy xyz router table that is really small, just to test ideas and programs on.
I think it is called "Dongda" and is a Chinese tabletop machine with approximately 400 mm x 300 mm movement, perfect for a test machine with small stepping motors
I look forward to any input to assist me in getting started.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- andypugh
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 19914
- Thank you received: 4662
19 Nov 2026 07:36 - 19 Nov 2026 07:39 #350829
by andypugh
Replied by andypugh on topic new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
A Raspberry Pi 5 (or maybe a 4) is a solid choice as it's a known quantity (they are all the same). It's not the most powerful of PCs and neither is it the cheapest at the moment, but it is at least known to work. Also the fact that it has built-in GPIO means that you can experiment with making motors spin with no additional hardware needed.
I recently bought one of these for a LinuxCNC conversion (I wanted dual ethernet ports). However I can't at this point recommend it, as the latency out-of-the-box isn't great. I am hoping that I can tune it somewhat.
I have a much more expensive Geekom PC that I use as a development system, that gives OK latency (but not the best I have seen).
I suspect that what you should get will depend very much on what you want it for. For just messing about with LinuxCNC then a Raspberry Pi 4 is much cheaper than a Pi 5, and with the addition of a breakout board like this you can play around with making LEDs come on from HAL etc without any further investment.
I recently bought one of these for a LinuxCNC conversion (I wanted dual ethernet ports). However I can't at this point recommend it, as the latency out-of-the-box isn't great. I am hoping that I can tune it somewhat.
I have a much more expensive Geekom PC that I use as a development system, that gives OK latency (but not the best I have seen).
I suspect that what you should get will depend very much on what you want it for. For just messing about with LinuxCNC then a Raspberry Pi 4 is much cheaper than a Pi 5, and with the addition of a breakout board like this you can play around with making LEDs come on from HAL etc without any further investment.
Last edit: 19 Nov 2026 07:39 by andypugh.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Zipdodar
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- andypugh
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 19914
- Thank you received: 4662
19 Nov 2026 07:40 #350830
by andypugh
Replied by andypugh on topic new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
I am bored of trying to get the last link to work with is execrable editor, the breakout I was suggesting is:
www.amazon.co.uk/GeeekPi-Raspberry-Termi...ansion/dp/B08GKQMC72
www.amazon.co.uk/GeeekPi-Raspberry-Termi...ansion/dp/B08GKQMC72
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- tommylight
-
- Away
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 22049
- Thank you received: 7509
19 Nov 2026 08:06 #350831
by tommylight
Replied by tommylight on topic new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
Have a look at these, maybe you can find something useful:
forum.linuxcnc.org/18-computer/54369-use...mesa-ethernet-boards
forum.linuxcnc.org/18-computer/57073-hp-...or-use-with-linuxcnc
forum.linuxcnc.org/18-computer/38838-har...ency-tests-used-pc-s
forum.linuxcnc.org/18-computer/54369-use...mesa-ethernet-boards
forum.linuxcnc.org/18-computer/57073-hp-...or-use-with-linuxcnc
forum.linuxcnc.org/18-computer/38838-har...ency-tests-used-pc-s
The following user(s) said Thank You: Zipdodar
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- tommylight
-
- Away
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 22049
- Thank you received: 7509
19 Nov 2026 08:16 #350832
by tommylight
Replied by tommylight on topic new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
It does work without installing, usually better than installed for latency, hence the install is more useful to be sure.I have read it is all about the latency and kernal which is software based and this needs to be good and right, and can only be tested once it is all installed..?
Yes they can, i have several new ones that work fine, had only one that was useless concerning latencyalso i am sure i have read that a newer pc is not good for linux and linuc cnc?
Can a new modern PC be used?
see my above post, real tests with used PC; and laptops, also some new PC's in there, maybe you can find something similar.if not what spec do i need to get and use?
Yes, you can use it without installing at all, even run machines without installing it, and there are many simulated configs included so you can play with and see what is more to your liking.But ideally, I want to do this in stages, so can I set it up on a pc or a raspberry pi or similer and play with it on the screen with nothing connected to learn stuff?
Yes, you can have as many setups as you like.- For testing and learning, Can I have multiple setups on the machine side and just one computer, then load each setup as and when required?
Yes of course, you can also have a config that uses both steppers and servos, and you can have configs that use Mesa or parallel port or EtherCAT, or any combination of those, or all in the same config.My plan is to have a board with a set of drivers, motors, switches etc.. as a test bed platform; this wil have both servos and steppers set up so both can be played with and tested.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Zipdodar
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- tuxcnc
- Online
- Elite Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 310
- Thank you received: 60
19 Nov 2026 11:30 #350840
by tuxcnc
Replied by tuxcnc on topic new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
As mentioned above.
A Raspberry Pi is a very modest computer, but it is a proven solution and will certainly get the job done. The real question is whether you intend to use it solely for controlling the machine, or if you also plan to run other software simultaneously. Low-power computers like this have a rather annoying trait: even when everything is running correctly, switching between the windows of different applications can take quite a while—in extreme cases, even several seconds. That’s fine when everything is working as it should, but it’s far too slow if something goes wrong and you need to react immediately...
I also use computers with Ryzen processors. I haven’t encountered any hardware-related issues; they run stably and with very low latency. Sometimes there are challenges with configuring LinuxCNC properly, but once that’s sorted out, you can rely on this hardware.
Unfortunately, Ryzen-based systems aren’t cheap, but you might look into second-hand, ex-lease computers—sometimes you can find a real bargain.
A Raspberry Pi is a very modest computer, but it is a proven solution and will certainly get the job done. The real question is whether you intend to use it solely for controlling the machine, or if you also plan to run other software simultaneously. Low-power computers like this have a rather annoying trait: even when everything is running correctly, switching between the windows of different applications can take quite a while—in extreme cases, even several seconds. That’s fine when everything is working as it should, but it’s far too slow if something goes wrong and you need to react immediately...
I also use computers with Ryzen processors. I haven’t encountered any hardware-related issues; they run stably and with very low latency. Sometimes there are challenges with configuring LinuxCNC properly, but once that’s sorted out, you can rely on this hardware.
Unfortunately, Ryzen-based systems aren’t cheap, but you might look into second-hand, ex-lease computers—sometimes you can find a real bargain.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Zipdodar
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Zipdodar
- Offline
- New Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 8
- Thank you received: 0
19 Nov 2026 11:31 #350841
by Zipdodar
Replied by Zipdodar on topic new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
Hi Andy
Thank you for your input. i may end up using Pi's and Pc's.
Is the Linux and LinuxCNC experience pretty much the same on either a Pi o a pc?
i.e wil it look and feel pretty much the same but possibly be slower or something?
Also, regarding latency, is this only important when trying to use Ethernet and EtherCATdrivers and connections?
the break out board looks interesting, can these be used in mulitples to increase connectivity?
Thank you for your input. i may end up using Pi's and Pc's.
Is the Linux and LinuxCNC experience pretty much the same on either a Pi o a pc?
i.e wil it look and feel pretty much the same but possibly be slower or something?
Also, regarding latency, is this only important when trying to use Ethernet and EtherCATdrivers and connections?
the break out board looks interesting, can these be used in mulitples to increase connectivity?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Zipdodar
- Offline
- New Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 8
- Thank you received: 0
19 Nov 2026 11:46 #350842
by Zipdodar
Replied by Zipdodar on topic new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
Hi Tommy
Thank you. So, when you say I can have them all on the same config,
I am assuming this means that if I have a machine that uses steppers and servos on different axis, even if controlled by parallel on some steppers and EtherCAT on others or servos, i can control this machine from one setup, config and control screen?
so it is basically one system, albeit a Frankenstein type build?
Thank you. So, when you say I can have them all on the same config,
I am assuming this means that if I have a machine that uses steppers and servos on different axis, even if controlled by parallel on some steppers and EtherCAT on others or servos, i can control this machine from one setup, config and control screen?
so it is basically one system, albeit a Frankenstein type build?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- tommylight
-
- Away
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 22049
- Thank you received: 7509
19 Nov 2026 11:53 #350843
by tommylight
Replied by tommylight on topic new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
Yes, and yes.I am assuming this means that if I have a machine that uses steppers and servos on different axis, even if controlled by parallel on some steppers and EtherCAT on others or servos, i can control this machine from one setup, config and control screen?
so it is basically one system, albeit a Frankenstein type build?
The following user(s) said Thank You: Zipdodar
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Zipdodar
- Offline
- New Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 8
- Thank you received: 0
19 Nov 2026 13:40 #350844
by Zipdodar
Replied by Zipdodar on topic new to lynux cnc, which computer to buy questions???
cool!
Perhaps I sound a bit sad, but to me that's exciting
Perhaps I sound a bit sad, but to me that's exciting
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.194 seconds