Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
- aventtini
- Visitor
11 Oct 2015 02:58 #63674
by aventtini
Replied by aventtini on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
I have also a mh500 that want to retrofit . I need some info on this philips scales . I was thinking to change them but they have a spacial place on the machine body and there is not room for a new one.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- uli12us
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 103
- Thank you received: 2
12 Oct 2015 02:30 #63696
by uli12us
Replied by uli12us on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
Heidenhain have similiar open scales, I fear because the scales are highly precise parts, they are not really cheap.
In the case of Mesa Boards the best way, were the scales with TTL-Output.
www.heidenhain.de/de_EN/products-and-app...tion-guide-for-lida/
In the case of Mesa Boards the best way, were the scales with TTL-Output.
www.heidenhain.de/de_EN/products-and-app...tion-guide-for-lida/
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- micges
- Topic Author
- Offline
- Administrator
Less
More
- Posts: 33
- Thank you received: 3
10 Jul 2016 01:06 #77240
by micges
Replied by micges on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
I removed old scales and installed new glass scales with 1um accuracy (5um should be enough for this machine).
I used those www.ateksensor.com/PDF_files/ENG/ALS4_Datasheet_ENG.pdf
They fit well into original places on machine.
I used those www.ateksensor.com/PDF_files/ENG/ALS4_Datasheet_ENG.pdf
They fit well into original places on machine.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- akb1212
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 108
- Thank you received: 12
10 Jul 2016 08:51 #77245
by akb1212
Replied by akb1212 on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
These scales looks like they are a good match to this machine yes.
I'm assuming you got the TTL output versions as they interface directly to the Mesa cards. But they have an option for 1Vpp output. With that you would be able to interpolate far better resolution. And that would be a good thing. I found my Maho MH600E behaves better and smoother when I use interpolators on my scales to increase resolution to 0,1um.
This was not to get better accuracy, but simply to get smoother movement.
The big question is where to get them, and what do they cost? If they are reasonably priced I'm assuming others here (me included) might be interested in getting some.
In the info they state there is an index pulse every 50 mm. That means you need to ensure it is within a certain position when starting a home search. Or else you might end up with a reference point that is a random multiple of 50 mm offset.
An alternative is to set up an extra sensor to tell it is within the correct range and can use the index pulse.
How are you solving this issue?
Anders
I'm assuming you got the TTL output versions as they interface directly to the Mesa cards. But they have an option for 1Vpp output. With that you would be able to interpolate far better resolution. And that would be a good thing. I found my Maho MH600E behaves better and smoother when I use interpolators on my scales to increase resolution to 0,1um.
This was not to get better accuracy, but simply to get smoother movement.
The big question is where to get them, and what do they cost? If they are reasonably priced I'm assuming others here (me included) might be interested in getting some.
In the info they state there is an index pulse every 50 mm. That means you need to ensure it is within a certain position when starting a home search. Or else you might end up with a reference point that is a random multiple of 50 mm offset.
An alternative is to set up an extra sensor to tell it is within the correct range and can use the index pulse.
How are you solving this issue?
Anders
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- micges
- Topic Author
- Offline
- Administrator
Less
More
- Posts: 33
- Thank you received: 3
10 Jul 2016 11:35 #77248
by micges
Replied by micges on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
I've used rs422 version and connect then directly to mesa 7i77.
I know that interpolated version could be better, maybe I'll do this next time.
As for homing I've used home switch that was mounted on machine,
I know that interpolated version could be better, maybe I'll do this next time.
As for homing I've used home switch that was mounted on machine,
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- andypugh
- Offline
- Moderator
Less
More
- Posts: 23536
- Thank you received: 4852
11 Jul 2016 13:49 #77292
by andypugh
Are the indexes all identical? I have heard of systems where the indexes are a variable number of counts apart, so after seeing two indexes you know where you are. Possibly also systems with indexes of different lengths.
Replied by andypugh on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
In the info they state there is an index pulse every 50 mm. That means you need to ensure it is within a certain position when starting a home search. Or else you might end up with a reference point that is a random multiple of 50 mm offset.
Are the indexes all identical? I have heard of systems where the indexes are a variable number of counts apart, so after seeing two indexes you know where you are. Possibly also systems with indexes of different lengths.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- akb1212
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 108
- Thank you received: 12
11 Jul 2016 19:37 #77308
by akb1212
Replied by akb1212 on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
I got this info from the online datasheets and know nothing more about them. And I don't know what kind of quality they are either, but I would like to know as they seem to be a good fit to this kind of machines. And they come in analogue 1Vpp versions, which means they can be interpolated to very high resolution. That is if they are true high quality units with reliable and clean sine curves on the output that is.
You are right Andy, it would be a good idea to have some form of pattern in the index pulses to allow for absolute address (kind of). It would take some logic in the homing sequence, but I guess that's no problem in LinuxCNC. But the datasheets are quite clear it's with 50 mm intervals.
So you do need extra hardware on a Maho. I've been able to keep my original (analogue) scales with index pulses only at the end, and therefore don't need to add home switches or any other hardware to make the homing work. The only danger with that is if you are beyond the index point in the other end you end up with a totally offset coordinate system. But you will be able to reset it simply in LinuxCNC. With the original 432 controller it wasn't so easy, in particular on the Y-axis where it was impossible to move the screw by hand as it has a brake to keep the table from sliding down when shut off. You had to do all kinds of trickery to get it to move past that index pulse.....
But the question still stands, how much do they cost? And where can I buy them?
Anders
You are right Andy, it would be a good idea to have some form of pattern in the index pulses to allow for absolute address (kind of). It would take some logic in the homing sequence, but I guess that's no problem in LinuxCNC. But the datasheets are quite clear it's with 50 mm intervals.
So you do need extra hardware on a Maho. I've been able to keep my original (analogue) scales with index pulses only at the end, and therefore don't need to add home switches or any other hardware to make the homing work. The only danger with that is if you are beyond the index point in the other end you end up with a totally offset coordinate system. But you will be able to reset it simply in LinuxCNC. With the original 432 controller it wasn't so easy, in particular on the Y-axis where it was impossible to move the screw by hand as it has a brake to keep the table from sliding down when shut off. You had to do all kinds of trickery to get it to move past that index pulse.....
But the question still stands, how much do they cost? And where can I buy them?
Anders
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- andypugh
- Offline
- Moderator
Less
More
- Posts: 23536
- Thank you received: 4852
11 Jul 2016 20:22 #77311
by andypugh
Try eBay. EXE are 11uA interpolators and IVB are 1V interpolators.
Replied by andypugh on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
But the question still stands, how much do they cost? And where can I buy them?
Try eBay. EXE are 11uA interpolators and IVB are 1V interpolators.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- micges
- Topic Author
- Offline
- Administrator
Less
More
- Posts: 33
- Thank you received: 3
11 Jul 2016 20:35 #77313
by micges
Replied by micges on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- uli12us
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 103
- Thank you received: 2
12 Jul 2016 15:06 #77342
by uli12us
Replied by uli12us on topic Retrofit MAHO MH700c with Philips 432 control
IC-haus sell some interpolator ICs with changeable interpolation. All of it can handle 11µA or 1,1V signals, dependent from the
installed passive parts. The price is much lower than the Exes. But you need a good soldering iron and can use it,
The main problem ist, the chips are birdsfeed, TSSOP 20 are really tiny chips.
The MG have software selectable interpolation, with a 20µm scale youcan select 5 for 1µm, 10 for 0,5µm, 25 for 0,2µm or 50 for 0,1µm.
The NV is a simpler Chip in the same small package, with it they are only hardware selectable interpolation factors from
1,2,5,10 all times 4 to have the resolution. The other possible factors 3,4,8,12,16 are not really meaningful.
installed passive parts. The price is much lower than the Exes. But you need a good soldering iron and can use it,
The main problem ist, the chips are birdsfeed, TSSOP 20 are really tiny chips.
The MG have software selectable interpolation, with a 20µm scale youcan select 5 for 1µm, 10 for 0,5µm, 25 for 0,2µm or 50 for 0,1µm.
The NV is a simpler Chip in the same small package, with it they are only hardware selectable interpolation factors from
1,2,5,10 all times 4 to have the resolution. The other possible factors 3,4,8,12,16 are not really meaningful.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: piasdom
Time to create page: 0.190 seconds