Home designed and built 5C CNC lathe with ATC and C_Axis

Thanks Andy - There are many of you willing to help, so I won't give up!

Regards
Joe

Reading a lot...Learning slowly, but learning!

Andy, I have some 'practical' questions regarding functions I wish to implement and am not sure if this is the better place to ask - I will ask here, but if inappropriate will start a new post else where.
Firstly, I have read as many posts as I could find on both subjects below, but have not found definitive direction for a solution.


I need to implement some form of spindle motor deceleration before stop on M command. The motor as I explained is a 2KW plus stepper - it is internally closed loop ( encoder, etc), can spin @ 2500rpm, 40NM torque, etc.
When spinning with the lathe inertial masses ( chuck, etc) and coming to an immediate halt, bad things happen! I have found a number of posts on this subject, but all refer to not disabling the motor enable signal when giving the stop command. I tried to simulate this manually - disconnected the enable from the MESA 7i76 and enabled permanently - ground to enable. Then run my Gcode file, spindle @ 500RPM, and then M02. Spindle slams to a halt - which stands to reason, as the motor is enabled and step pulses cease so motion ceases as fast as possible.
I then set the spindle @ 500RPM again, enable active, and then set enable inactive ( remove the connection to ground manually)
The motor slams to a halt again - The motor can be rotated by hand when stopped, with enable inactive, same as when the motor is just turned on, but not enabled - it can be rotated, but is stiff. The motor still 'slams' to a halt in this test due to the re-generation effect in the motor creating a powerful magnetic brake. At 1000rpm, removing the enable, the motor comes to a standstill within 1-1/2 to max 2 revolutions!

So, playing with enables won't work - I need to actually decelerate the motor with decreasing step pulse frequency.
I also tried using 'spindle at speed' modes - and set the speed in the Gcode file to slower speeds, expecting L_CNC to wait till the spindle speed is achieved before the next speed command - did not - ran through the Sxxx commands in one shot..
The wait till speed reached works in the cnc file - the next G0 or G1 commands seem to pause till preceding spindle speed commands are achieved.

The second is a bigger project...To implement a C axis with the same Spindle Stepper motor.
Again, I have read all I could find, but the poster knew far more than me each time, and was able to glean solutions from replies that I am unable to understand!

Thank you for any help!
Joe

In this type of situation you would typically limit the spindle speed rate of change
with VFD programming but since you are using a servo you would need to limit
the rate of change in LimuxCNC's commanded spindle speed. This can be done with
the "limit2" component. By passing LinuxCNCs commanded spindle speed through the
limit2 component, you can now specify the maximum rate of change in spindle speed
(in RPM/Second)

man limit2

Enable brings an additional complication in that LinuxCNC now has to wait for the spindle
speed to reach 0 before removing the spindle enable when stopping.

I am going to ask for more concerted help please..!

Still trying to implement a spindle deceleration before stop on my spindle step/dir servo

I have attached my current HAL file. Would one of you experts be so kind as to take a look and add to it the items/terms required to implement the limit2 function indicated by PCW. It does not have to be perfect, but at least all the parameters that are needed to be set up, the nets needed, etc, in terms of the signal names as used in my HAL file. This should at least help me to understand how these things tie together and allow me to follow the required connections and statement in the file in my so far futile attempts at understanding the HAL file...

I spent the whole day today digging through forum postings - did not find any examples that made sense to me ( there are very few by the way) - I also spent hours contemplating the Spindle Example in docs/html/examples/spindle.html - many terms are 'similar' to the names in my HAL file, but not exact and I have no idea how to assimilate that example's names and nomenclature into my file! Since it appears one can choose any name for anything it is hard to understand if my 'spindle-at-speed' is the same one as the one in the example file!

This is the example:
# load real time a limit2 and a near with names so it is easier to follow
loadrt limit2 names=spindle-ramp
loadrt near names=spindle-at-speed

# add the functions to a thread
addf spindle-ramp servo-thread
addf spindle-at-speed servo-thread

# set the parameter for max rate-of-change
# (max spindle accel/decel in units per second)
setp spindle-ramp.maxv 60

# hijack the spindle speed out and send it to spindle ramp in
net spindle-cmd <= spindle.0.speed-out => spindle-ramp.in

# the output of spindle ramp is sent to the scale in
net spindle-ramped <= spindle-ramp.out => scale.0.in

# to know when to start the motion we send the near component
# (named spindle-at-speed) to the spindle commanded speed from
# the signal spindle-cmd and the actual spindle speed
# provided your spindle can accelerate at the maxv setting.
net spindle-cmd => spindle-at-speed.in1
net spindle-ramped => spindle-at-speed.in2

# the output from spindle-at-speed is sent to spindle.0.at-speed
# and when this is true motion will start
net spindle-ready <= spindle-at-speed.out => spindle.0.at-speed

My file has a 'spindle-at-speed' which also appears in the use of the near component in the spindle section of the file, but in the example, at the top, there is a
loadrt near names=spindle-at-speed.
My file just says
loadrt near
how does my files 'near' even know of the name 'spindle-at-speed' when done this way??

Hard to understand from this lack of 'conformity' how the elements connect and are used!
I also looked at the man limit2 -
That was not really much help - all that documentation works fine if you already know it all...

Limit2 is described such in linuxcnc.org/docs/html/man/man9/limit2.9.html :

limit2 - Limit the output signal to fall between min and max and limit its slew rate to less than maxv per second. When the signal is a position, this means that position and velocity are limited.
Fine, that is understood.
then :
loadrt limit2 [count=N|names=name1[,name2...]]
Loadrt - fine
count=N - also understood
Then, what are the names and to what do they need to refer to or connect to??
There is no 'english' explanation I could find that explains each element and term, the dependencies etc.
then the pins list:

limit2.N.in float in
limit2.N.out float out
limit2.N.load bit in

When TRUE, immediately set out to in, ignoring maxv

limit2.N.min float in (default: -1e20)
limit2.N.max float in (default: 1e20)
limit2.N.maxv float in (default: 1e20)
Again, with no explanation of implementation , it is not possible for ME to 'pass LinuxCNCs commanded spindle speed through the
limit2 component, and specify the maximum rate of change in spindle speed' !!

Sheesh, for what is actually a very simple function I am trying to implement, this is difficult!

Thank You!
Joe

My file just says
loadrt near
how does my files 'near' even know of the name 'spindle-at-speed' when done this way??

It does not, if you use "near" you must only load it once so you either use
named instances or numbered instances, you cannot use both at once

Thanks for responding PCW,

It does not, if you use "near" you must only load it once so you either use
named instances or numbered instances, you cannot use both at once


Where does one find the rules that those in the know state so easily?
I was not implying the use of both at once - I simple did not know that they were equivalent in some fashion - and no matter how hard I dig in those docs, that knowledge does not seem to be there.

My file has at the start:
loadrt near
( no names, no numbers)
then
addf near.0 servo-thread
( another 'near', with a number, but a servo thread..)

Then:
net spindle-vel-cmd-rps => near.0.in1
net spindle-vel-fb-rps => near.0.in2
net spindle-at-speed <= near.0.out
setp near.0.scale 1.000000
setp near.0.difference 1.666667

The example has :
loadrt near names=spindle-at-speed
then:
net spindle-cmd => spindle-at-speed.in1
net spindle-ramped => spindle-at-speed.in2

So I can see some indication of what you said about names and numbers -
I presume 'my' near.0.in1 = the example's spindle-at-speed.in1 ?

Anyway, I think I have asked enough times, pleaded...and am just starting to annoy people. I am not really getting anywhere, so thanks for everyone's indulgence and patience, but this is just to much pain with very little advancement for too long!

As I indicated earlier, the only reason for trying to go the route of Linuxcnc was because of the C_Axis for this lathe. But that is still a pipe dream, what with the basics being so elusive. I realise L_CNC is very versatile considering what other folk have managed to do with it, and naively thought a Basic Lathe would be a doddle...Such a pity it is such a hurdle, when options like MACH3/PlanetCNC, etc are so easy to configure and make work for simple setups like a 2 axis lathe.

Was a project with good intentions!

Thanks again to everyone, will leave you all in peace now!

Regards
Joe